Digital signature vs electronic signature: what each one is, and how one PDF carries both
An electronic signature is a legal idea: any electronic mark or action a person adopts with the intent to sign, such as a typed name or a signature drawn on a phone. A digital signature is a technology: a value computed from a file with a private key, which lets anyone check that the file has not changed since it was signed and which certificate signed it. They are not alternatives. A well-made signed PDF usually carries both.
The difference at a glance
| Electronic signature | Digital signature | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Any electronic sound, symbol or process adopted with the intent to sign | A cryptographic value computed over a file’s bytes with a private key |
| What it shows | That a person meant to sign this record | That the file is unchanged since signing, and which certificate signed it |
| What it looks like | A typed name, a drawn signature, a ticked box | Usually nothing on the page; a PDF reader shows it in a signature panel |
| How it is made | Typing, drawing, clicking, entering a PIN | Software using a private key and its certificate |
| Who applies it | Each person who signs | A person holding a certificate, or a service sealing the finished file |
| How it is checked | Through the audit record kept with it | By any PDF reader that validates signatures, even offline |
| US law | Defined in the ESIGN Act and state UETA laws | Counts as an electronic signature when a person uses it to sign; the law does not require it |
What is an electronic signature?
The federal ESIGN Act, at 15 U.S.C. 7006, defines it as “an electronic sound, symbol, or process, attached to or logically associated with a contract or other record and executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the record.” Typed names, drawn signatures, click-to-agree boxes and PINs all fit. The definition turns on the person’s intent, not the method, which is why the law can treat a typed name and a smart-card signature alike. What is an electronic signature? covers the types and the record that should go with one.
What is a digital signature, and how does it work?
A digital signature uses public-key cryptography. The US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency describes it as “a mathematical algorithm routinely used to validate the authenticity and integrity of a message” (CISA, Understanding Digital Signatures). In outline:
- Software computes a hash of the file: a short fingerprint that comes out completely different if a single byte changes.
- A private key, held only by the signer or the sealing service, signs that fingerprint. The result is stored with the file; in a PDF, inside the file itself.
- A certificate ties the matching public key to a name. It is issued by a certificate authority, a third party that checks who it is issuing to.
- Anyone checking the file recomputes the fingerprint and uses the public key to test the signature. A match means the file is unchanged and was signed with that key.
Two standards make a digital signature useful years later. A timestamp under RFC 3161, issued by an independent timestamp authority, shows when the signature was made by that authority’s clock rather than the signer’s or the service’s. And PAdES, the European standard for digital signatures inside PDF files (ETSI EN 319 142), lets any reader that follows it check the file.
How the two work together in a signed PDF
SignThis, an e-signature service, uses both on every document:
- Each signer signs electronically. They open a personal link from their email, agree to the electronic records disclosure, and draw, type or photograph their signature into the fields marked for them. That is the electronic signature: the act, and the intent behind it.
- Every step is recorded. Sent, opened, consented, signed: each goes into a hash-chained audit trail with times recorded by the server.
- The finished file is digitally signed. When the last person signs, the final PDF is built with every completed field and sealed with a PAdES digital signature and an RFC 3161 timestamp. Any change to the file afterwards shows the seal as broken.
- Anyone holding the file can check it. Open it in a PDF reader that validates signatures, or drop it on the verify page, which computes the file’s fingerprint in your browser and sends only the fingerprint.
The two layers answer different questions. The electronic signatures and the audit certificate show who agreed, how each person was reached and when. The digital seal shows that the file in your hands is the file they signed. How SignThis seals a signed document goes through each part, and how to check whether a signed PDF has been altered shows what a PDF reader reports.
Personal digital signatures: a different thing
Some people mean something narrower by “digital signature”: a signature made with the signer’s own certificate. Three common examples:
- US government smart cards. The federal Personal Identity Verification (PIV) card carries a “Digital Signature” certificate and key pair that lets the holder sign a document or email, used with a card reader and software on the computer (GSA, PIV 101). The Defense Department’s Common Access Card holds certificates that let cardholders sign documents digitally (DoD, CAC security).
- Certificates bought from a certificate authority and installed in a PDF or office program, used by some professionals and firms.
- Qualified electronic signatures in the EU, based on a qualified certificate from a qualified trust service provider and made with a qualified signature creation device. Under the eIDAS Regulation these have the same legal effect as a handwritten signature.
Here the cryptography identifies the person: the certificate says who holds the key, and an authority checked that before issuing it. It also asks more of every signer: a certificate, often a card and reader, and software that can use them. So it appears mostly where an agency, an employer or a regulation names it, such as US federal systems and European transactions that call for a qualified signature.
A service seal works the other way round. One certificate belongs to the service and covers the whole finished file, after everyone has signed. Signers need only a browser, and who each of them was rests on the audit record: the personal link sent to their email address, any access code the sender set, and the time they consented and signed.
Which one do you need?
- An ordinary agreement in the US, such as a contract, an NDA, a lease or an offer letter: an electronic signature with a good record behind it. For agreements like these, the federal ESIGN Act and the state UETA laws generally put an electronic signature on the same footing as a handwritten one. Wills are outside both laws, and ESIGN also leaves out family-law matters, court documents and certain notices. A digital seal over the result makes any later change detectable.
- A form or system that names a method: follow it. If an agency says to sign with your PIV card, or a European counterparty asks for a qualified signature, that instruction decides.
- A tax form: the IRS sets its own rules form by form. See does the IRS accept electronic signatures?
To get an ordinary agreement signed both ways at once, upload the PDF to SignThis, place the signature fields and send it. On the free plan, 3 documents a month are free. Upload a PDF and send it.
Common questions
Is a digital signature the same as an electronic signature?
Not quite. A digital signature is one way to make an electronic signature, and also a way to seal a file that no person signs by hand. When a person applies one to sign, it is an electronic signature in the legal sense. Most electronic signatures, though, are not digital signatures.
Is a digital signature more legally binding than an electronic signature?
In the US, not by itself. ESIGN and UETA do not give one signing technology more legal weight than another; a digital signature’s advantage is evidence, because it shows the file is unchanged. In the EU, a qualified electronic signature has, under Article 25 of eIDAS, “the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature.”
Why does my PDF reader say a signature’s validity is unknown?
Usually because the reader does not recognise the authority that issued the certificate. The line that matters for tampering is the one saying whether the document was modified after it was signed.
Is a scanned signature a digital signature?
No. A scan is a picture of ink. It can be an electronic signature if you place it intending to sign, but nothing in the image ties it to the rest of the file.
Do signers need a certificate to sign with SignThis?
No. Each signer signs through a personal link in their browser, and the service applies the digital seal to the finished PDF.
This is general information about signature law and technology, not legal advice. The official sources linked above were read on November 18, 2026.